Ready to find your highly profitable Airbnb? Enter your details below...
We don’t focus on rental arbitrage, hotels, or glamping.
If that’s your focus, this call likely isn’t the right fit.
What would you prefer to do? *
Owning a profitable Airbnb that generates substantial monthly cash flow is more attainable than ever. Picture receiving booking notifications, watching your calendar fill up, and seeing thousands of dollars deposited into your account each month while building long-term wealth. But how do you know if a property is a financial winner or a hidden money pit? The key lies in conducting a complete ROI analysis before making any investment decisions, including following a comprehensive cash-on-cash return guide that relies on accurate occupancy rate calculations to evaluate your potential returns accurately.
One metric stands out when evaluating short-term rental investments: Cash-on-Cash (CoC) return. This calculation reveals the true annual yield on your invested money, unlike looking at purchase price or gross revenue alone. Since accurate CoC returns depend on reliable occupancy rate calculations, investors new to this methodology should start with our detailed cash-on-cash calculation guide that breaks down the process step-by-step. Combined with a comprehensive investment calculator and complete ROI analysis, it's the clearest picture of how hard your investment dollars are working.
This guide will answer what constitutes a good cash-on-cash return for an Airbnb, show how to calculate it for any property using our detailed cash-on-cash calculation guide, and reveal strategies used by top investors to find above-average properties. Our comprehensive ROI calculator and analysis methods have helped STR Search clients acquire over $90 million in high-performing short-term rental properties after analyzing thousands of investments.
Cash-on-Cash (CoC) return is the annual pre-tax cash flow of a property divided by the total cash invested, expressed as a percentage. It measures how much cash the property returns to you annually compared to your initial investment. For step-by-step calculations, see our detailed cash-on-cash calculation guide.
While Cash-on-Cash return focuses on your investment and cash flow, Cap Rate (Capitalization Rate) is calculated as Net Operating Income divided by the total property price. Cap Rate ignores financing, assuming an all-cash purchase.
A property with an 8% Cap Rate might deliver a 15-20% CoC return when purchased with financing. That’s why many sophisticated investors focus on CoC: it better reflects the power of leverage and how most people invest (with mortgages, not all cash).
CoC Return = ((Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow / Total Cash Invested) x 100%)
Let's break that down. First, calculate two key components to get your final number.
Annual Pre-Tax Cash Flow = Gross Rental Income - Operating Expenses - Annual Debt Service
Gross Rental Income: This includes all revenue generated by your property, including nightly rates, cleaning fees, and other guest charges. New investors often rely on overly optimistic projections from sellers or agents. At STR Search, we use actual performance data from comparable properties to create realistic revenue models.
Operating Expenses: This category includes all costs of running your STR business:
Annual Debt Service: This is your total mortgage payments for the year (principal + interest). For a typical 30-year loan, multiply your monthly payment by 12.
Total Cash Invested = Down Payment + Closing Costs + Renovations & Furnishing Costs
Down Payment: For investment properties, this typically ranges from 15-25% of the purchase price, depending on the loan type.
Closing Costs: Typically 2-5% of the purchase price, including:
Renovation & Furnishing Costs: This is a major variable for STRs that new investors underestimate. Creating an "Instagrammable" space that commands premium nightly rates is an investment, not just an expense. Depending on the property size and condition, expect to spend $15,000-$40,000+ on furniture, décor, kitchen supplies, linens, smart home technology, and renovations.
Many investors consider a CoC return of 8-12% to be "good" for traditional long-term rentals. This benchmark has been standard in real estate investing for years, and many rental property owners are satisfied with returns in this range.
This makes sense for long-term rentals with minimal management and stable income. Once tenants are in place, there's little work involved beyond occasional maintenance.
Short-term rentals involve more work, higher operational complexity, and greater risk than traditional rentals. You're dealing with:
At STR Search, we don't seek "good" returns; we seek "excellent" ones. We target properties for our clients projecting a CoC return of 15% or higher. This standard has been delivered across our $90M+ in transactions. Given the effort and risk in short-term rentals, investors deserve superior returns.
Finding high-performing STR investments is difficult. Most investors face major challenges:
The biggest obstacle is unreliable data. Relying on Airbnb's "potential earnings" estimates or a seller's optimistic projections often leads to disappointment. Real-world expenses are underestimated, while revenue projections are inflated.
Then comes analysis paralysis: spending hours researching properties, verifying numbers, and second-guessing decisions. Meanwhile, the best properties get snatched up by more decisive investors.
Finally, there's the fear factor. For first-time STR investors committing significant portions of their savings or retirement funds, making a million-dollar mistake is a legitimate concern.
This is why we developed our proven 4-step process.
Step 1: Data-Driven Market Identification: We analyze thousands of data points across hundreds of markets to find the most profitable opportunities, not just the most popular ones. We look at occupancy rates, seasonal patterns, regulatory environment, and growth trends to identify markets with the highest return potential.
Step 2: Curated Property Matching: We hand-pick properties that meet our strict performance criteria and match your investment goals, timeline, and risk tolerance. No more sifting through irrelevant listings.
Step 3: Live Deal Analysis: We walk you through the numbers on available properties, showing how we project a 15%+ CoC return. You'll see real-time calculations, realistic expense projections, and revenue models based on comparable properties.
Step 4: Acquisition Support: We guide you through the purchase process, from offer to closing, ensuring expert support at every step.
The financing structure significantly impacts your CoC return. A lower down payment (e.g., 10-15% with a second home loan vs. 25% for an investment loan) can dramatically increase your CoC, even with slightly lower monthly cash flow.
For a property worth $400,000:
The lower down payment option delivers a superior return on your invested capital, despite the lower monthly cash flow.
Every renovation dollar should be viewed through the ROI lens. A $5,000 hot tub might increase annual revenue by $10,000, making it a no-brainer investment. Meanwhile, a $20,000 kitchen remodel might only increase revenue by $2,000.
Focus on the elements that drive bookings and higher nightly rates:
Static pricing is leaving money on the table. Using sophisticated pricing tools to adjust rates based on:
This strategy can increase annual revenue by 15-30% compared to fixed pricing.
The tax advantages of STR investing can equal the first year’s down payment for high W-2 earners, creating a near-infinite effective CoC return.
Many investors can use their STR losses to offset W-2 income, saving tens of thousands in annual income taxes, by using strategies like bonus depreciation, cost segregation studies, and meeting the material participation threshold.
You understand that Cash-on-Cash return is the key metric for evaluating STR investments. By traditional standards, 8-12% is "good," but the goal for successful short-term rental investors is 15%+. You have the formula to calculate CoC for any potential investment and insight into the factors that influence this number.
Knowing the formula is one thing; the real challenge is finding the right properties. While many investors spend months or years searching for the perfect property, our clients find and close on high-performing investments within 30-90 days. Our data-driven process and 100% success rate across $90M in deals provide the most reliable path to STR investment success.
No. ROI (Return on Investment) is a broader term that includes all forms of return: cash flow, appreciation, mortgage paydown, and tax benefits over the investment's life. Cash-on-Cash return focuses on the annual cash flow relative to your initial cash investment. It's a snapshot of your annual cash performance rather than a complete lifetime return calculation.
Yes. If your annual expenses and debt service exceed your gross income, you’re losing cash each year and have a negative CoC. This defines a bad investment that STR Search helps clients avoid. Properties with negative CoC require you to feed them money monthly instead of generating income, a situation that can quickly drain your resources and create financial stress.
Seasonality is crucial in STR performance. Use annual projected data that accounts for high and low seasons, not just a busy month. For example, a beach property might generate 60% of its annual revenue in three summer months, while a ski property does the same in winter. Using only peak-season data for annual projections will lead to miscalculations and financial disappointment. This highlights the importance of sophisticated data analysis from experts who understand seasonal patterns in different markets.
Trusted by hundreds of successful investors
We’ve spent years analyzing what works so you don’t have to. Our job is to cut through bad data and help you make smart, profitable decisions backed by real numbers.
Schedule Your Free Call
