Ready to find your highly profitable Airbnb? Enter your details below...
We don’t focus on rental arbitrage, hotels, or glamping.
If that’s your focus, this call likely isn’t the right fit.
What would you prefer to do? *
Many travelers dream of visiting Maui's beaches and landscapes, but savvy investors see an opportunity to own a piece of paradise that generates income. With strong tourism, premium property values, and impressive rental rates, Maui consistently ranks among the best Airbnb investment markets. However, this market comes with a critical caveat: it's one of the most regulated and complex STR environments in the U.S. For those seeking alternatives, exploring undervalued Airbnb markets may offer similar returns with fewer barriers to entry, while investing in Maui without expert guidance is risky and leads to costly mistakes.
This is not a travel blog listing scenic spots. This is a definitive investment guide breaking down regulations, analyzing data, and revealing true opportunities for serious investors seeking immediate returns and long-term appreciation in the Maui market—whether you're targeting premium locations or exploring how Maui compares to other top Airbnb investment markets for maximum ROI potential.
At STR Search, we use advanced data analytics to help investors find and acquire high-performing short-term rentals in the best Airbnb investment markets. We eliminate the guesswork with a 100% success rate across over $90 million in transactions. Our approach replaces speculation with data, providing a clear path to successful STR investing in complex markets.
Disclaimer: This guide is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. The Maui short-term rental market and regulations are complex and subject to change, and while Maui ranks among the best Airbnb investment markets, each investor's situation is unique. Consult a qualified local attorney and a CPA for your specific situation.
When considering Maui real estate investing, look past the postcard-perfect beaches and palm trees. From an investment perspective, Maui represents a blue-chip opportunity with strong fundamentals regardless of market conditions. The island's status as a top travel destination creates resilience that few markets match, consistently ranking among the best Airbnb investment markets. While vacation hotspots experience boom-and-bust cycles, Maui has demonstrated staying power, consistently attracting high-income visitors willing to pay premium rates for quality accommodations.
The strength of the Maui STR market isn't just anecdotal. It's supported by impressive performance metrics:
Before you can reap these rewards, you must master the most critical aspect of the Maui market: the rules.
Understanding Maui's STR regulations is essential for a successful investment strategy. Most unguided investors fail. Only properties in specific zones or with specific permits can be legally short-term rented (less than 180 days). Purchasing a property without verifying its legal STR status risks financial disaster.
Hotel Zoning (H-M, H-1, H-2, etc. in county maps). Properties in these zones are designated for "transient accommodations," meaning they can be rented for less than 180 days without a special permit.
Most legally operating STR condos in Maui fall into this category, making hotel-zoned properties the primary target for investors. These properties have higher purchase prices but offer clear legal status and potential for strong returns.
Many desirable condos in Ka'anapali, Wailea, and parts of Kihei are hotel-zoned, providing investors with options in prime tourist areas. These properties feature resort amenities that command premium nightly rates.
In 1997, the Minatoya Opinion Letter created a special category of legally operating STRs. This opinion grandfathered a specific list of apartment-zoned condo complexes operating as STRs before certain regulatory changes.
The "Minatoya List" includes a finite number of buildings. If a condo is in one of these complexes, it can be legally operated as a short-term rental despite not being in a hotel zone. This limited supply creates scarcity and strong value for these properties.
These properties can represent excellent investment opportunities, as they are priced lower than hotel-zoned condos while still providing legal STR status. It is essential to verify that a property is genuinely on the Minatoya List, as misinformation is common.
Unlike the previous categories for condos, STRH and B&B permits apply to residential homes. The permit process is highly competitive, with strict caps per community plan area and a lottery-based system with long waitlists.
For new investors entering the Maui market, waiting for a permit is not a viable strategy. The realistic approach is to purchase a property with a transferable permit, but these properties are rare and command significant premiums.
Most investors should focus on the condo market, where legal status is tied to zoning or the Minatoya List rather than individual permits.
When considering a Maui property for STR investment, follow this checklist:
Now that you understand the legal landscape, let's use data to pinpoint the best place to Airbnb in Maui for your investment goals. Each region offers unique advantages and appeals to different travelers, resulting in varied investment profiles.
The Vibe: West Maui offers the classic Maui resort experience many travelers dream about. This area embodies the island's upscale leisure reputation with championship golf courses, luxury resorts, famous beaches like Ka'anapali Beach, and consistent tourist traffic.
Investment Profile: The West Maui market is dominated by high-rise and low-rise hotel-zoned condos, making them viable for STR operation. These properties have higher entry prices but command premium nightly rates. They appeal to travelers seeking a full-service resort feel with amenities like pools, restaurants, and concierge services. This area is strong for Kaanapali Airbnb investors looking for proven performance.
Key Data:
The Vibe: South Maui has two distinct submarkets. Wailea represents luxury with high-end shopping, 5-star hotels, and pristine beaches. Kihei offers a laid-back, affordable atmosphere popular with families, featuring great beaches and a central location.
Investment Profile:
Wailea is Maui's most prestigious and expensive market. Properties are luxurious, low-density hotel-zoned condos. They offer the highest ADR potential on the island but come with the highest acquisition costs. For investors with substantial capital seeking Wailea condos, this area offers unmatched luxury positioning and strong appreciation potential.
Kihei: This area offers a wider range of prices. Many complexes are on the Minatoya List or hotel-zoned. Kihei properties perform well due to high demand and slightly lower (but still strong) ADRs. This area is ideal for investors seeking a Kihei short-term rental with a balance of affordability and performance.
Key Data:
Ma'alaea: This small, central harbor town offers a more affordable entry point to the Maui STR market. Several large condo complexes allow STRs. The location is known for good windsurfing and its central position makes it convenient for exploring the island. For value-oriented investors, Ma'alaea presents an opportunity to enter the market at a lower price while achieving solid returns.
A Note on Lahaina: Following the tragic August 2023 fires, Lahaina is in a long-term recovery phase. Out of respect for the community, and due to current market uncertainty, we’re focusing this guide on other viable investment areas on the island. We support the people of Lahaina and the recovery efforts.
Navigating this complex market requires a proven system. At STR Search, we use a proprietary 4-step process to ensure our clients invest in top-tier properties. Here's how we apply this methodology to the Maui market:
For high W-2 earners, taxes are a significant financial drag. A strategically chosen Maui investment property can effectively reduce your tax burden while building wealth through a tangible asset in a premium market.
Material Participation is a game-changer for high-income professionals. By actively managing your STR (or using a qualifying management structure), you can classify losses from the property against your active income (W-2). This means that even while your property may be cash-flow positive, it can generate "paper losses" for tax purposes that offset your high-bracket income.
Bonus Depreciation and Cost Segregation amplify this tax advantage. A cost segregation study allows you to accelerate the depreciation of property parts. In 2024, this can create a large "paper loss" in the first year, directly offsetting your regular income.
Imagine purchasing a $1.2M Wailea condo. A cost segregation study might identify $300,000 in assets eligible for bonus depreciation. This creates a large paper loss that significantly reduces your taxable income for the year, saving tens of thousands in taxes while building equity in a premium asset.
Maui is a world-class STR market with exceptional revenue potential and a strong appreciation track record. However, success depends on navigating the complex Maui STR regulations governing short-term rentals on the island.
The best Airbnb location in Maui depends on your goals, with West and South Maui offering the best options for investors seeking legal clarity, strong returns, and appreciation potential. Whether you prefer the resort atmosphere of Ka'anapali or the diverse prices of Kihei, success lies in data-driven decision-making.
A data-driven partner like STR Search removes risk and maximizes your potential return by ensuring you consider only properties that meet strict legal requirements and offer strong financial performance.
Q: Can I manage my Maui Airbnb from the mainland?
A: Yes, it's common. Hawaii law requires an on-island contact person for guest or emergency issues. Most owners hire a local property management company to handle guest communications and maintenance.
Q: What are the typical property management fees in Maui?
A: Fees range from 20% to 35% of gross rental revenue, depending on the service level and company. Full-service management that handles everything from marketing to maintenance is on the higher end.
Q: Do I have to pay Hawaii's Transient Accommodations Tax (TAT)?
A: Yes. All STRs are subject to the state TAT and Maui County TAT. As of 2024, the combined rate is 17.25%. Platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo collect and remit this on your behalf, but it's the owner's responsibility to ensure compliance.
Q: Is financing an investment property in Maui different?
A: Financing a "condotel" (a hotel-zoned condo) can be more challenging. It often requires a larger down payment (typically 25-30%) and working with lenders who specialize in these properties. Many mainland banks are unfamiliar with Hawaii's property classifications.
Trusted by hundreds of successful investors
We’ve spent years analyzing what works so you don’t have to. Our job is to cut through bad data and help you make smart, profitable decisions backed by real numbers.
Schedule Your Free Call
